Thursday, July 24, 2025

Composite vs. Wood Decks: The Bennington Homeowner's Real-World Guide



When we decided to replace our 15-year-old pressure-treated wood deck, I assumed we'd just go with wood again. That was before I spent an entire summer staining, sealing, and sanding splinters out of little hands. A neighbor mentioned composite decking, but was it really better? I turned to Hunt Home Remodeling's Deck Installation Guide and discovered some surprising truths about both options.

The Great Decking Debate
Here's what I learned from Hunt's experts about today's decking landscape:

Wood Deck Reality Check
The Good:

  • Lower upfront cost (about $15-$25/sq ft installed)

  • Traditional look many homeowners love

  • Easier to repair individual boards

The Not-So-Good:

  • Requires annual maintenance (average $300-$500/year)

  • Lifespan of 10-15 years in Nebraska's climate

  • Splintering and warping over time

  • Susceptible to insect damage

Composite Deck Deep Dive
Why It's Gained Popularity:

  • 50-year warranties on premium products

  • No staining or sealing ever

  • Resistant to fading and scratches

  • Eco-friendly options using recycled materials

What You Should Know:

  • Higher initial cost ($25-$45/sq ft)

  • Can get hotter than wood in direct sun

  • Not all composites are created equal

Bennington-Specific Considerations
Hunt's local experience revealed key factors for our area:

  1. Temperature Swings: Composite handles freeze-thaw cycles better

  2. Humidity: Wood expands/contracts more dramatically

  3. Maintenance: Composite saves about 20 hours/year of upkeep

  4. HOA Rules: Some neighborhoods have material restrictions

The Hidden Cost Calculator
When I compared 20-year costs:

  • Wood: $8,000 (installation) + $7,000 (maintenance) = $15,000

  • Composite: $14,000 (installation) + $500 (cleaning) = $14,500

Why We Chose Composite
After seeing Hunt's Trex samples and talking to neighbors:

  • Time Savings: No more weekend sealing projects

  • Safety: No splinters for bare feet

  • Consistency: Uniform color that won't weather unevenly

  • Warranty: 25-year coverage on fading/staining

Pro Tip from Hunt
"Invest in quality hidden fasteners - they prevent moisture buildup under composite boards and give a cleaner look."

Final Decision
We went with Hunt's recommendation of Trex Transcend in Spiced Rum - it looks like real wood but with none of the hassle. Six months in, we've hosted two birthday parties, countless cookouts, and haven't touched a sander once.

Tags: #DeckMaterials #BenningtonLiving #LowMaintenance #OutdoorSpaces #HomeInvestment

No comments:

Post a Comment

Why Douglas County Homeowners Keep Rethinking Their Deck Layouts (And How to Avoid Costly Regrets)

  1. Introduction If you’ve spent any time in Douglas County, you know how much we love our outdoor living spaces. Backyard barbecues, summe...